Chief Financial Officers (CFOs) of publicly traded companies often find themselves in an interesting paradox. CFO compensation packages are among the highest in the corporate world, yet their tenure in these roles remains significantly short. This dynamic raises questions about the challenges and opportunities faced by CFOs today.
CFO Compensation Boost Coupled with High Turnover
Research by Datarails analyzed data from 1,657 of the top listed U.S. companies. The findings reveal that CFOs continue to have the shortest average tenure in the C-suite, at just 3.1 years—a decline from 3.5 years two years ago. Despite this, CFO compensations have the highest year-over-year pay increases among executives, averaging a 9% rise between 2022 and 2023. This increase more than doubles the 4% average bump seen across other leadership roles.
In 2023, Joe Berchtold from Live Nation pulled in a whopping $52.4 million, while Michael J. Cavanagh from Comcast made an impressive $41 million. Despite such lucrative packages, the role’s high turnover highlights the complexity and intensity of CFO responsibilities.
Why CFO Turnover is So High
CFO skills and roles demand a rare combination of accounting expertise and strategic financial acumen. This dual requirement has made CFOs indispensable yet heavily scrutinized. Factors contributing to high turnover include:
Increased Responsibility - CFOs are expected to manage not only financial reporting but also broader strategic initiatives, such as implementing AI solutions within the finance department.
Demand for Work-Life Balance - Beyond compensation, CFOs value work-life balance, decision-making autonomy, and opportunities for collaboration within their leadership roles.
Market Opportunities - The growing demand for top-tier CFO talent has created a competitive landscape, with many finance chiefs transitioning to roles offering better perks or flexibility.
Industry Tenure Trends and the "CFO Carousel"
The length of CFO tenures varies significantly by industry.
CFOs in the hospitality and cruise industries and satellite companies enjoy the longest tenures.
Industries like broadcasting, professional services, and airlines report average tenures of 3.6 to 3.5 years.
Conversely, CFOs in agriculture and utilities have some of the shortest tenures, averaging 2.7 years.
Interestingly, roles in professional sports, such as Major League Baseball CFOs, often come with tenures exceeding a decade. However, these positions, characterized by prestige and perks, were not included in the Datarails study.
High turnover isn’t limited to individual CFOs. Many companies experience rapid changes in financial leadership. Nearly half of U.S.-based firms in the study—about 48%—said they’ve had at least one CFO change in the last five years. Some organizations, like Jack in the Box, underwent a staggering five CFO changes between 2018 and 2024. This frequent turnover underscores the challenges companies face in retaining top financial talent.
Other companies with notable CFO turnover include Dollar General, eBay, Expedia, Guess, and Under Armour. The reasons for this phenomenon range from changes in organizational strategy to the lure of better opportunities elsewhere.
CFOs as Stepping Stones to CEO Roles
A growing trend is seen in CFOs transitioning into CEO roles. In 2023 alone, 15 of 16 internal CEO promotions were awarded to former CFOs. This trend reflects the increasing recognition of CFOs’ strategic value and their ability to drive organizational growth and transformation. Companies are beginning to see their CFOs as natural successors to the CEO, further emphasizing the importance of the role.
Balancing Compensation and Retention
While the high CFO compensation packages aim to attract and retain top talent, they don’t always ensure longevity in the role. Companies must consider factors beyond financial incentives to retain their CFOs, such as:
Offering greater autonomy in decision-making.
Promoting cross-departmental collaboration.
Prioritizing work-life balance and flexible work arrangements.
By addressing these factors, organizations can create a more sustainable environment for CFOs, reducing turnover and fostering long-term success.
The Future of CFO Leadership
As the responsibilities of CFOs continue to evolve, so too will the expectations placed on them. The growing integration of technologies like AI in financial operations is just one example of how the role is expanding. To thrive in this dynamic environment, CFOs need to balance their technical expertise with strategic vision and leadership skills.
In turn, companies must rethink how they support their CFOs, offering not just competitive compensation but also opportunities for professional growth and meaningful impact. This holistic approach will be critical in attracting and retaining the next generation of financial leaders.
Comments